All The Pope’s Men was an interesting book. When I started reading it I was expecting more of a theological expose of how the Vatican works, but to my surprise this was not the case. This was not a bad thing, but a very good thing. It allowed me to step back and see the church in a whole new light. As Catholics we see the Vatican as this holy place, which it is, but it is so much more. It is literally a country of its own, and it has diplomatic relations with other countries. I think that is one of the reasons for the book’s popularity. It gives detailed insight into the different aspects and offices that comprise the Vatican. I found it particularly fascinating that the various offices of the Vatican are totally autonomous from each other. They each have their own separate leadership. In the pages about the Roman Curia Allen wrote about how one office was comprised of two people who spoke two different languages. This was done so they would not develop a favoritism toward each other.
Another reason for the book’s popularity is that it is not a theological treatise or a church history book about the importance of the Vatican. Allen strives and succeeds in my opinion, between the roll of the Holy See and its relationship with the rest of the world. A third reason for the books popularity is that it acts as a myth buster about popular conspiracy theories about the Vatican. I recommended this book to a non-Catholic friend for those pages alone. They are filled with sources that can be easily obtained. Allen’s views on the American and Vatican perspectives is also interesting, and if you look closely you can see them play out pretty regularly. In America we want things done the way we want yesterday (immediately). The Vatican doesn’t work that way. It is a 2,000 year old Institution that moves slowly. It isn’t because it doesn’t care, but because it is concerned with Catholics worldwide not just in Los Angeles, CA. Because of that there are times where relations between the two seem strained, but overall relations are good. Overall I give the book 4 out of 5 stars.
You can check the book out here.